Owning A DSO - Do you really need a Digital Storage Oscilloscope to fix cars? - Motor Age - Automotive training, certification & parts info

Owning A DSODo you really need a Digital Storage Oscilloscope to fix cars?

Source: Motor Age

During the last 10 years, I’ve worked in a variety of shops and, to date, have been the only tech that owned a DSO. When techs see it in use for the first time, they invariably ask what I’m doing and why — and then ask if they should own a scope of their own. While most have been capable of repairing problems without one, let me share a few examples of why they could have accomplished the same thing in less time and with more assurance their repair would be the correct one.

A Little Background
Automotive scopes have evolved significantly since the days of the old analog Sun models I grew up with. In those days, scopes were used primarily to view secondary ignition patterns in real time. I remember reading about techs around the country who were using the scope to test other electrical systems and sensors, and started playing with the techniques I learned from them. The only problem with the analog scope was the inability to freeze a capture for a closer inspection. If the fault was intermittent, it was that much more difficult to catch.

The DSO, or Digital Storage Oscilloscope, is akin to the Digital Multimeter (DMM) in that it doesn’t trace a voltage signal in real time. It samples the signal and reproduces that sample on the screen as a graph of voltage over time. The sample points then are connected by the DSO to form a pattern you can view. The faster the sample rate, the more accurate the screen trace will be.

This isn’t an article on exactly how a DSO works; there have been plenty of those already written. Suffice it to say, the sample rate on even the slowest DSOs is light years faster than any DMM on the market. Today’s DSOs also have the ability to record these samples over an extended period of time, allowing you to store and later review the patterns recorded, and that makes finding intermittent faults a lot easier.

DSOs are available as handheld units, or as a PC-based application. Some include databases of specific tests for specific components, and can preset the voltage and time divisions for you. There are two-, four- and eight-channel units available (a channel is one measurement — think of it as one voltmeter lead, with one reading displayed). DSOs vary quite a bit in their sample rates and buffer sizes. When choosing a scope, remember this bit of advice my Dad gave me when I was a teenager, wanting to buy a stereo.

“Son, there’s no sense in buying a $500 stereo if you only have a $50 pair of ears.”
In other words, match your scope to your ability and budget. As your skills in using one grow, so will your knowledge of exactly what you want in your next one.

 

PAGE 2

Do You Really Need One?
There isn’t enough space in the pages of this issue for me to share all the instances where using a scope helped me diagnose and repair a problem. A DSO has the ability to measure circuits and signals that operate at speeds too fast for a conventional DMM. Consider an example: You want to verify the electrical integrity of a fuel injector circuit.

This circuit is only on for a matter of milliseconds — about the same amount of time it takes for an ignition spark to jump a plug gap. A DMM is useless for this test, but a DSO is more than capable and the resulting pattern can tell you everything you want to know about the electrical health of the tested circuit if you know what to look for.
Another common use for DSOs is crank and cam sensor testing.

Sure, you can check for power and ground to these sensors, but a DMM can’t tell you if the signal from the sensor is correct and steady. The DSO pattern can tell you both, and aids in finding an intermittent loss of any input signal the control module needs to carry out its duties.

 
As one noted instructor once said, "Any scope is better than no scope." Match your first scope to your abilities and budget when making your choice.

A DSO is a useful tool for checking signal relationships, too. By measuring the signal of both sensors at the same time and comparing them to a known good pattern, you can tell if the sensors are in time with one another. Sensors found to be out of synch can be the result of a jumped timing belt and sensor signals that bounce around in relationship to one another can be an indication of a worn timing chain. There is a Ford TSB that uses this relationship to check for improperly installed cam sensor synchronizers on their models, and the TSB shows what a good pattern should look like. (In the old days, you had to collect your own, but today there are several on line resources available.)

Any voltage signal can be verified and tested using the DSO, whether it be input or output. This makes a DSO excellent for “If this, then that” troubleshooting. By monitoring an input signal and looking for the correct output signal, you can make sure that the control module is acting on its programming and test a given system while it is actually operating, just like the control module does.

It’s Not Just Voltage
A DSO is limited to reading voltage, but that doesn’t mean it can only measure voltage. There are scope accessories that convert current, pressure, vacuum and even temperature into voltage signals that the DSO can read and trace. This adds even more usefulness to the DSO as a diagnostic tool.

PAGE 3

One of the first additions to my scope was a high and low amp probe. These accessories measure current flow, and convert it to a voltage signal the DSO can see. Monitoring current in an injector or ignition primary circuit aids in diagnosing problem coils or control module driver issues. I’ve used current monitoring to find intermittent A/C compressor clutch engagement problems, detect faults in relay controlled circuits and to help identify weak fuel pumps, just to name a few examples.

Current is what makes a component work, and watching what that current does as a component operates can speed up diagnosis. Can you measure current with your DMM? Sure, but by tracing that reading over time, I can tell a lot more about what is going on in that circuit than you can.

One of the first diagnostic tricks I learned with the DSO, and still use routinely, is the relative compression test that measures the current used by the starter. Simply, weak cylinders cause a lower current draw in the starter and that can be measured and traced on a DSO screen. If a weakness is detected, I next connect a pressure/vacuum transducer to the oil dipstick tube and repeat the test.

 
A scope can be handheld or PC based, and offer two, four or eight channels for measurement. They also vary in capability (sampling rate and recording) and in the specific features available.

If the second pattern is OK, I know the fault is in the valvetrain…if not, it’s in the piston and/or rings. In a matter of minutes, I can get a quick picture of the engine’s mechanical health. Compare that to the time it would take to perform a conventional compression and cylinder leakdown test on a modern, transverse engine.

Measuring pressure and vacuum is nothing new, but a relatively new expansion on this idea is measuring the running pressure in a given cylinder. This is an exciting idea, allowing you to perform one test that will allow you to see exactly what is going on in an individual cylinder on a running engine. Intermittent sealing issues, exhaust backpressure problems and valve timing faults are just a few of the problems that can be easily identified and confirmed using this test. Here, there is no substitute test that I know of that can tell you so much in such a short time.

Do you need a DSO to fix today’s cars? No, you don’t. But the addition of a DSO to your diagnostic arsenal will help you fix more of the ones you just guessed at and missed, saving you time and money in the process.

post a comment
Your email address will NOT be published.
appears with your comment
read our privacy policy
Note: does not support HTML
All comments submitted are subject to review and may be delayed before posting. We reserve the right to not publish comments.
Got something to say about it? Post it here!
 Posted 2009-08-22 05:16:47.0
I found this article to be very interesting. I have been one of those techs who has been repairing cars with rare use of a DSO for the last twenty five years. And while I find it useful, taking the time teach yourself that which you are not familiar with can be a bit of a challenge, working flat rate your main concern is fix it is as short a time as posibble and move on. Another obstacle is having easy access to instructional information and guidance from a competent sources. I am not saying these obstacles are by any means insumountable, but do require a determined effort and longer range vision of the intended goals and rewards. It is not always easy to keep this perspective in the day to day grind and trying to balance family home life and other included interest. It is articles like this that give me the desire to continue to strive to become a better technician. Thanks
 Posted 2009-08-24 10:20:36.0
Hi Pete Excellent article. I especially liked the part where you do a quick check of relative compression and follow that with a quick check for blow-by into the crankcase via the dipstick port. The use of the FirstLook ES 100s with any DSO allows this type of test to be done very quickly from the exhaust pipe and from the dipstick port also. Plus many other non-invasive tests that can rapidly provide very valuable information about any automotive engine...or any diesel engine too!
Read More Comments
SERVICE REPAIR NEWS
Messe Frankfurt joins forces with Spanish trade fair
Historic Denman Tire in trouble
Edmunds.com notes used car prices rise, except recalled Toyotas'
CPFilms introduces automotive window film for the digital age
New tire from Yokohama poised to clean up in sanitation situations
SHOP PRODUCTS
Pit racks accommodate many vehicles
Fuel pump socket removes nuts
Bed mat offers protection
Tire features low rolling resistance
LED whitelight includes mounting bracket
Survey
Does your shop work with any race teams, whether it's for service, parts or advertising support?
Yes
No
Yes
25%
No
75%
View Results
Thanks for sharing info about your shop!
E-News envelope

Check the e-newsletter(s) you would like to receive.

Rollover each title for information.

Distribution - Anyone interested in auto parts issues will enhance their business by subscribing to our Distribution newsletter from Aftermarket Business. Published every Tuesday and Friday.
Collision Repair - Our Collision Repair newsletter from ABRN provides up-to-date news, innovative products, technical discussions and shop management features designed to enhance your business. Published every Tuesday and Friday.
Service Repair - Sign up today for Service Repair news from Motor Age. Benefiting auto technicians, this e-newsletter provides the latest news and analysis, technical automotive service information and business management tips. Published every Monday and Thursday.
Certified Technician - Professional automotive technicians and parts distributors seeking aftermarket products should sign up for the Certified Technician e-newsletter. This is your source for information about the latest tools, equipment and parts that can help you better service your customers. Published every Monday and Thursday.

Source: Motor Age,
Click here